MP vs USAR — which stock performed better?

MP Materials (MP) versus USA Rare Earth (USAR), Materials, on 2026-11-06.

Result

USA Rare Earth (USAR) performed better on 2026-11-06. MP moved 1.370%, USAR moved 5.920%.

Why these two companies

China's one-year pause on expanded rare-earth export controls is set to expire on November 10, 2026, keeping investors focused on the two U.S. companies racing to build a domestic rare-earth supply chain, a contrast The Motley Fool laid out on November 5. The timing is sharp for this matchup: MP Materials released its third-quarter results after the close on Thursday, November 5, so the market's verdict on that report plays out right at the open of the session this game covers, while USA Rare Earth does not report until November 9. With both stocks already pushed toward 52-week lows heading into the China deadline, the pairing sets an established, scaled producer against an early-stage challenger still building its supply chain from scratch.

The research

MP Materials runs the only large rare-earth mine and processing plant in the United States, turning mined ore into the materials used in powerful magnets. USA Rare Earth is trying to build a similar mine-to-magnet business, but it is newer and still in the early stages of actually producing and selling material.

One reason to like MP Materials is that it already has real, fast-growing sales from an operating facility, backed by government support including a guaranteed price floor. One reason to like USA Rare Earth is that it has secured close to a billion and a half dollars in funding commitments, including a large award tied to a U.S. government program, giving it financial runway to build out its plans.

Both stocks have been falling for weeks, and the smaller, newer company has tended to swing more sharply than the larger one on any given day. Keep in mind that MP Materials just released its latest earnings after the market closed on November 5, so the reaction to that news will show up right as this game's trading session begins, while USA Rare Earth will not release its own results until several days later.

Also worth remembering: a major U.S.-China agreement affecting rare-earth exports is due to expire on November 10, just days after this game, which could sway both stocks together no matter which one wins on this particular day.